China's booming aquaculture industry relies increasingly on fishmeal made from wild-caught fish. A new study, which is published in Science presents a more sustainable alternative to the current practice. Photo: M. Troell/Azote

China's booming aquaculture industry relies increasingly on fishmeal made from wild-caught fish. This practice risks depleting wild fish stocks and strains fragile ocean ecosystems, but a new study offers a more sustainable path.

The new study, which is published in Science, by a research team including Max Troell, Patrik Henriksson and Marc Metian from the Stockholm Resilience Centre and the Beijer Institute of Ecological Economics, offers the clearest picture to date of China’s enormous impact on wild fisheries. The group of researchers also presents a more sustainable alternative to the current practice of using wild-caught fish to feed farm-raised fish.

One-third of global supply
China is the world's leading producer, consumer and processor of fish, contributing one-third of the global supply. China's fish production has tripled in the past 20 years, and about three-quarters of its supply now comes from fish farms.

"Yet the industry still places pressure on wild fisheries through its demand for fishmeal and fish oil made from wild-caught species” says Max Troell, co-author of the study. "How China develops its aquaculture and aquafeeds sector can thus tip the balance of global seafood availability," he continues.

"There is a clear opportunity for positive change, but the economic and regulatory incentives for such change are not yet in place," says Rosamond Naylor, the William Wrigley Professor in the School of Earth Sciences and director of the Center on Food Security and the Environment at Stanford.

Fishing in the coastal waters of China is poorly regulated and often indiscriminate. The result is large volumes of assorted "trash fish" – species that are unfit for human consumption – that end up in animal feeds, including in fishmeal that is fed to farm-raised fish. Many of the stocks of wild fish used for feeds have been fully exploited and many of those targeted in mixed fisheries overexploited, and reducing the demand for them can help protect fragile ocean ecosystems.

Recycling waste
One promising solution is to recycle the waste by-products from seafood processing plants across China. This waste, which can be 30 to 70 percent of the incoming volume of fish, is often discarded or discharged into nearby waters.

The team's analysis shows that these processing wastes could satisfy between half and two-thirds of the current volume of fishmeal used by Chinese fish farmers, replacing much of the wild fish currently used in feeds.

Quality and food safety are two potential barriers to replacing wild-caught fish with fish processing wastes. The waste is lower in protein that wild-caught fish, but this can be overcome by adding plant-based protein sources to the fishmeal, like algae or ethanol yeast. The use of processing waste also raises concerns about contamination and disease transmission, which the researchers say can be addressed through better research on the safety risks and through tighter regulations.

A more sustainable path
"It's time to make serious decisions about managing and protecting ocean fisheries, and China will play a pivotal role in this process," concludes Rosamond Naylor. "Collecting good data from China is an important starting point. But we also need a clear path toward more sustainable fisheries and aquaculture management, and that's what we present in this paper."

"This is a critical juncture for China," said lead author Ling Cao, a postdoctoral scholar at the Center on Food Security and the Environment. "If the country makes proactive reforms to its aquaculture sector, like using fish-processing wastes instead of wild fish, and generally reducing the amount of fishmeal in aquafeeds, it can greatly improve the sustainability of the industry. If not, the consequences for the entire global seafood supply chain are going to be really serious."

Link to the Science article